The Career Rules Nobody Says Out Loud
A candid talk on getting promoted, navigating politics with “soft skills” (including the cost of missteps), and the hard truth about PIPs
Hi, it’s Ethan & Jason from Level Up: Make career breakthroughs with AI-proof leadership skills.
Thrilled to share both of our one-day AI workshops are trending on Maven. Join us to upskill fast and leave with workflows you can apply immediately:
(May 9) Claude Cowork Certification: Build skills that work. A 4-hour, hands-on workshop to become a real Claude builder and save > 1 hour/day with practical automations, prompts, and repeatable systems. Limited seats.
(May 17) AI PM Certification: From Specs & Evals to Leadership Sign-off. Raise the bar for your AI PM workflows with sharper specs, better evals, and clearer go/no-go decisions. Perfect for teams to attend together.
Stack Ranking & PIPs, Working With Jeff Bezos, & Promotions
Watch on YouTube.
In this talk, you will learn the unglamorous truth about how careers actually work in big companies: why “being right” isn’t enough, how promotions really happen, why performance management systems often fail people, and what to do if you are stuck under a tough manager.
Presented in partnership with Visuals Creation
Think like a Founder, not a creator. The executives building real authority online aren’t spending hours in editing software because they are recording their ideas and letting a strategic team handle the rest.
That is exactly what Visuals Creation does for you.
From high-end talking heads and vlogs to short-form reels, we deliver every format professionally and on time. Your content stays consistent, your audience grows, and your brand becomes undeniable.
Here’s a clip they made of Jason explaining how managers and direct reports can use 1:1 time to align on and drive career goals.
Use code VC20 for 20% off your first 3 months exclusively for Level Up readers.
Key Takeaways
Own the pattern, not the blame. If you keep hitting the same wall (e.g. conflict, stalled growth, getting managed out), assume you are part of the problem and change your approach. Early in his career, Ethan was let go twice due to being abrasive and combative with peers. In his first performance review, his manager wrote “I think sometime’s Ethan’s solutions to problems would be ‘let’s knock their heads together.’” The turning point was recognizing the common denominator (himself) and asking, “What do I need to do differently?”
“Soft skills” are the force multiplier (not the nice-to-have). Technical ability can carry you early, but it will not protect you from politics or peer conflict. After being let go, Ethan described his accomplishments in an interview and the interviewer replied: “Everything you say sounds fine, but I just really struggle to believe that if you were that valuable, these companies, even though they were struggling, wouldn’t have found a way to keep you around.” Ethan realized the interviewer was right and that his gap wasn’t technical ability or results — it was how he worked with people. He rebuilt his approach: lead with questions, listen more, influence without unnecessary escalation, and still hold boundaries to not get steamrolled. More on soft skills.
Be “strategically annoying,” not abrasive. Pushy is often necessary to win resources, make decisions, and get promoted — but how you push determines whether people back you or go around you. Loud pressure creates enemies, skillful pressure creates momentum. A difference maker is alliance building. If you strongly disagree with person A, you need enough trust with B, C, and D that they will defend or inform you when you are being shut out. Relationships and how people feel about working with you matter as much as being right.
Promotions are performance + narrative + necessity. The career changing proof is: “If you pulled this person out, it would not have happened.” Build ownership around outcomes where your absence would change the result, then make sure leadership sees that storyline clearly.
At ~10,000 employees, being promoted from Senior Manager to Director at Amazon meant (1) you were one of the 100 most important leaders in Amazon; (2) you could lead a business or major effort on your own and only needed high-level goals.
Most leaders reward the squeaky wheel (even if they hate admitting it). When promotion slots are limited and candidates are equally qualified, the person who advocates (politely) often gets prioritized over the silent hard worker — because managers triage risk and retention pressure.
Use “The Magic Loop” to form a win-win partnership with your manager. Align on “I will do everything you need done (go above and beyond), and you (manager) do one critical thing that gets me rewarded for it (promotion).” Promotions do not just “happen to you” — you and your manager must team up and run a process together. It took Ethan’s VP 2.5 years to be ready to put his credibility on the line and co-drive Ethan’s promotion to Amazon VP.
No deal is real if you don’t know the process. When you make this partnership, confirm that you and your manager understand the promotion mechanics, deadlines, and required artifacts. A promise without a process is relying on hope. More on how to manage your promotion process and your promotion document framework.
Founder’s can metaphorically take the whole company to Las Vegas and bet it on black (they can take gambles that others won’t). In a budget discussion with Jeff Bezos, the CFO at the time was trying to slow down Jeff’s spending on a project and said “Well, you know Jeff, we only have so much money in the bank.” Jeff looked at him and replied “Well, Tom, how much is that? Because I might want to spend it.” Ethan thrives under a leader who asks tough probing questions and enthusiastically commits “Okay, I’m on board. Let’s do it. We’ll do it together!” He found Jeff both inspiring and supportive.
Beware of “zombie products” in big companies. You can hit goals, ship features, and still fail the vision — because the org confuses “checking boxes” with building something truly valuable. That is how products linger: killing them is politically hard and feels like admitting failure, but no one has a credible plan to make them big either. So they just “bump along.”
The goals paradox (why leaders don’t fix the scorecard). Leaders hesitate to reset goals toward the vision because they will be judged on the new targets. That creates tension between the goals that matter most for the company and the goals leaders have a clear path to hit for their performance review and compensation.
Performance management is messier than you want it to be (companies stink at it because they don’t train managers how to do it effectively). Stack ranking and attrition targets can force managers to act, but performance improvement plans (PIPs) are often a combination of dishonest and psychologically stacked against the employee once the decision is made (the cognitive bias is already “This person will be removed soon”). If you land on a PIP, treat it like a countdown and run a job search in parallel. More on PIPs and stack ranking reality.
Fun fact: Pre-college, Ethan wrote Apple a physical letter “Hey, I want to come work at your company, how do I do that?” Apple explained that they only hired engineers from 5 universities at the time (Stanford, Caltech, Berkeley, Carnegie Mellon, and MIT). Ethan went to Carnegie Mellon.
Watch Ethan and Ryan’s round 2 talk — a deeper dive into corporate politics, empire building, reorgs, firing managers, and what senior level promotions really take.
If this talk resonated, share it with one friend or teammate navigating promotions, politics, or a tough manager — so they can make their next move with eyes open.
AI did not just change how work gets done, it changed how fast your role can become obsolete.
In the next newsletter, we will revisit The Magic Loop and why it is more critical than ever in a world of AI-driven automation, reorgs, and layoffs.
You will see how AI can help you run the loop faster — by freeing time, sharpening your development plan, and acting as an “AI coach” to rehearse the tough conversations with your manager.
The core truth has not changed: trusted relationships + increasing value are what protect your job (AI or no AI).
Keep an eye on your inbox.
Connect With Ethan & Jason
Follow Ethan on LinkedIn.
Get our career advice on YouTube.
Connect with Jason (Ethan’s Co-Founder & COO) on LinkedIn.
Learn more about our live online courses and on-demand courses.
Contact us for corporate training, keynote speaking, guest writing, and more.
Join our Level Up Slack Community of 1300+ members and 23 specialized career channels with active peer support.
Reach out if you want to sponsor this newsletter trusted by leaders and builders scaling companies and careers across Fortune 500s, Big Tech / FAANG, and high-growth startups.
The point about careers having a lot of unwritten rules is so true. One place I see this a lot is in job descriptions. They look like neutral role descriptions, but they often reveal the same hidden rules you’re talking about: how decisions get made, how much ambiguity exists, whether the team is under-resourced, and whether the company actually knows what it wants from the hire.
That’s especially dangerous for people trying to make a move into tech, because they often read JDs too literally. They focus on whether they match the bullets, when they should also be reading between the lines. I shared some examples here from my own job search:
https://consulting2tech.substack.com/p/5-red-flags-hidden-in-tech-job-descriptions